Beyond Amethyst: The Conference

This past Friday I attended a conference at Hampshire College about the drinking age and whether it should be changed. Alex Torpey, a graduating student , organized the conference as part of his Division III, or senior project.

Ralph Hexter introduced the keynote speaker and indicated that he feels the issues around the drinking age and drunk driving hinge on responsibility. President Hexter is a signer of the Amethyst Initiative which called for lowering the drinking age to eighteen.

The keynote speaker was Barret Seaman, author of Binge: What Your College Student Won’t Tell You. Formerly an editor for Time, he now sits on the board of Choose Responsibility. Choose Responsibility is a not -for-profit advocacy group started by John McCardell, the former president of Middlebury College and the originator of the Amethyst Initiative.

Seaman spoke about changes in college drinking since the 1960’s. Drinking has increased and many students now engage in a practice called pre-gaming. Pre-gaming involves drinking, often heavily, prior to going to a party or event. Annually, there are 1700 deaths of young people from drinking not related to driving.

Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) argues that the 21 year old drinking age has saved lives and that there has been a13% decrease in traffic deaths. Seaman , however argued that other countries with a lower drinking age have had bigger decline.

In the pursuit of harm reduction, Seaman feels colleges and parents need to change the idea of alcohol as ‘forbidden fruit’. According to him, the age of first use has been steadily declining in the twenty-five years since the drinking age was raised.

Seaman recognizes that the drinking will probably not be changed any time soon and argues for measures that will deal with the problem right now, including medical amnesty and offering safe rides.

After Seaman’s speech, there were three workshops. The first had the Dean of Students from Hampshire and Smith College, the public safety officer for Smith, Hampshire and Mount Holyoke and the public safety officer from Amherst College. The two Dean of Students discussed the medical amnesty policy of the two colleges. This is also a harm reduction model. In the case of Smith, if a student must  go to the hospital because of alcohol abuse, the emergency room sends a report to the Smith doctor, who is the only person who will know the student’s blood alcohol content (BAC). The student then meets with  the doctor. If there is a second offense the school has the right to let parents know. All of the speakers stressed that most students find themselves in this situation only once. They all also see the policy as a helpful, educational one and not punitive.

The next workshop was, on “The Pleasure Plateau” and the presenter was Emily Nagoski, the Wellness Education Director, Student Affairs  from Smith College. She often meets with students, using a stages of change model for the interaction.The four stages are pre-contemplation, contemplation,action and maintenance. She tries to meet the students where they are, support their autonomy and freedom of choice, support their ambivalence around their behavior and the possibility of change, and to roll with their resistance to change.

She was a very lively presenter and I  think she would be great with students. Emily explained that alcohol has a bi-phasic effect on the drinker. In the beginning  you feel good, less inhibited and appear attractive. The more you drink the worse you feel. Eventually you drink enough that you can face a medical and sometimes fatal emergency.

Biphasic Curve

The final presenter was David Hanson, a retired sociology professor from the State University of New York at Potsdam. He also maintains a website, Alcohol: Problems and Solutions. He discussed the dichotomous views that people can have about alcohol; alcohol as inherently bad or bad only if it is abused. According to Hanson, alcohol is neither good nor bad but a neutral substance. He feels the federal government supports the view of alcohol as inherently bad and therefore seeks to reduce consumption.

He encourages people to”think outside the box” about solving abuse of alcohol. He cited the case of Anchorage, Alaska which now offers $1000 to any package store owner who collects a false id. The state doesn’t pay the $1000 however, the person who attempted to buy alcohol illegally does.

Another idea he has was a drinking learner’s permit similar to a driver learners permit. This would invole stages of access to alcohol, achieved after passing educational courses.

The conference was very interesting and a great achievement for an undergraduate student. The few questions I have involve the solo focus on alcohol. On most college campuses there are many psychoactive substances available, not just alcohol. Any solution to alcohol abuse must also deal with the abuse of other drugs.

Alcohol is a psychoactive substance; I think this means it is not a neutral substance and helps explain our society’s ambivalence towards it. Finally I feel when we discuss our culture’s approach to alcohol and contrast it with other societies that may be more lenient, we must include information about the pyshiological effects of alcohol. Cirrhosis is the tenth leading cause of death in Amerrica. Recently other countries,including Britian, have seen a rise in this disease.

13 thoughts on “Beyond Amethyst: The Conference”

  1. Hi – I don’t comment on many web sites but had to on yours. It’s really nice! I really like how you write – very to the point, unlike a lot of other blogs. Thanks for having this site. I don’t have time to read all the information here right now, I found this site when looking for something else on, but I’ve bookmarked your homepage and will check back soon to see what’s new. I really appreciate you having this website. As someone who has struggled with an addiction myself, I have started a site devoted to information about it. Visit my site if you’d like to read more. Keep up the outstanding work!

  2. Aloha! I want to say gracias for an interesting website about a something I have had an interest in for a long time now. I have been lurking and reading the posts frequently and just wanted to express my thanks for providing me with some very good articles. I anticipate reading more, and taking a more involved part in the conversations on this site.

  3. The definitions surrounding alcohol, alcoholics, alcohol abuse, well, they are extremely open-ended, sometimes can seem very subjective, and at best confusing. No two people really have the same definition or idea about what alcohol abuse really is. Each person experiences alcohol in such a different way. It causes so many different physical, and physiological changes in people, it is hard to set boundaries broad-range and across the board.

  4. Maybe you could change the page title Beyond Amethyst: The Conference Amy Mittelman Brewing Battles Blog to more specific for your subject you make. I enjoyed the the writing even sononetheless.

  5. I adore it when article writters have their own take on theme, I respect them all. How come the blog writter does not share and blog about last year’s incident?

  6. It is actually rare to find informed individuals on this subject issue, nevertheless, you sound like you understand what you are preaching about! Thx

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: